Old City Prime

Old City Prime A modern day classic American steakhouse. Old City Prime is a modern day classic American steakhouse. Our menu is a revival of ageless taste.
(1224)

From our fresh oysters and chilled seafood, classic tableside salads, gourmet appetizers, USDA prime aged steaks to breads and desserts from our in house bakery.
​
Indulge in our classic cocktails and boutique wine list, and we think you'll find yourself comfortably enjoying our vision of what today's supper club should be.

✨Entrée Spotlight✨Steak & Langostino ScampiFeaturing an 8oz Wagyu sirloin paired with lobster langostino in a garlic lem...
06/23/2026

✨Entrée Spotlight✨
Steak & Langostino Scampi

Featuring an 8oz Wagyu sirloin paired with lobster langostino in a garlic lemon scampi sauce.

Available for a limited time at Old City Prime.

https://www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

Blue point oysters. Chilled shrimp prawns. Cold lobster cocktail. The Iced Seafood Plate is how you open a summer evenin...
06/22/2026

Blue point oysters. Chilled shrimp prawns. Cold lobster cocktail. The Iced Seafood Plate is how you open a summer evening right. Come in. Sit down. Let us take care of the rest.

Third Thursday is here! 🍸🦪🍤Join us tonight at Old City Prime and enjoy 3 Shrimp Cocktail or 3 Oysters for just $5 from 5...
06/18/2026

Third Thursday is here! 🍸🦪🍤

Join us tonight at Old City Prime and enjoy 3 Shrimp Cocktail or 3 Oysters for just $5 from 5–8 PM.

See you downtown!

Begin your dining experience with our featured appetizers. ✨Enjoy Crispy Fried Green Tomatoes with Creole Remoulade and ...
06/17/2026

Begin your dining experience with our featured appetizers. ✨

Enjoy Crispy Fried Green Tomatoes with Creole Remoulade and Beef & Vegetable Asian Dumplings—available for a limited time on our Feature Menu.

Reserve your table today:
https://www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

This Father’s Day, treat Dad to an evening at Old City Prime 🥩🥃Exceptional steak. Fine bourbon. Unforgettable experience...
06/15/2026

This Father’s Day, treat Dad to an evening at Old City Prime 🥩🥃
Exceptional steak. Fine bourbon. Unforgettable experience.

Gift cards available online or in-store:
https://www.oldcityprime.com/gift-cards

New Feature Menu has arrived at Old City Prime 🥩✨A curated selection of elevated cuts, seasonal inspirations, and chef-d...
06/13/2026

New Feature Menu has arrived at Old City Prime 🥩✨

A curated selection of elevated cuts, seasonal inspirations, and chef-driven dishes designed to showcase the very best of the moment.

Experience it for yourself — available for a limited time only.

Make your reservation:
https://www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

Candlelight. Prime steaks. A wine list worth lingering over. Old City Prime is the kind of place that turns a dinner res...
06/11/2026

Candlelight. Prime steaks. A wine list worth lingering over. Old City Prime is the kind of place that turns a dinner reservation into a memory. Make yours tonight — visit our website or call 419-22PRIME.

Congratulations on 70 remarkable years together. It was truly our honor to be part of your celebration.
06/10/2026

Congratulations on 70 remarkable years together. It was truly our honor to be part of your celebration.

A modern classic American steakhouse — right here in the heart of Downtown Lima. From the first oyster to the last sip, ...
06/08/2026

A modern classic American steakhouse — right here in the heart of Downtown Lima. From the first oyster to the last sip, Old City Prime is the night out you've been meaning to plan. What are you waiting for?

Tonight at Old City Prime, we had the privilege of celebrating something truly special.A wonderful couple joined us to c...
06/07/2026

Tonight at Old City Prime, we had the privilege of celebrating something truly special.

A wonderful couple joined us to celebrate their 73rd wedding anniversary. Seventy three years of commitment, faithfulness, perseverance, and love is a rare gift and an inspiring reminder of what it means to build a life together through every season.

It was an honor to be part of their celebration and to share in such a meaningful milestone. Their joy, warmth, and appreciation for one another filled the room and made the evening memorable for everyone who had the chance to meet them.

Please join us in congratulating this remarkable couple on 73 years of marriage. Thank you for choosing Old City Prime to celebrate such an extraordinary occasion. We wish you many more blessings and happy memories together.

Happy 73rd Anniversary from all of us at Old City Prime. ❤️🥂

Address

215 S Main Street
Lima, OH
45801

Opening Hours

Monday 5pm - 9pm
Tuesday 5pm - 9pm
Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 5pm - 9pm
Friday 5pm - 9pm
Saturday 5pm - 9pm

Telephone

+14192277463

Website

, ,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old City Prime posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share