The Old Fashioned Supper Club

12/12/2025

❄️🥶 It may be freezing outside, but our food is HOT! 🔥
And if that’s not enough, our old fashioneds will warm you up even faster 🥃

Swing on in tonight for:
🐟 Our delicious hand-breaded fish fry (golden fried, baked or blackened)
🥩 Succulent steaks cooked to perfection
🍝 Fresh pasta made with love

Bundle up, head over, and enjoy a truly relaxing evening with us. We’ll keep you warm! ❤️🔥

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Clubs Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens MKEeeeEats Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

12/06/2025

I'm not sure about you but I feel like Cabin Fever is starting to set in with all of this snow & the frigid temperatures 🥶

We're looking extra forward to our Saturday night prime rib - not only is it encrusted but we're injecting it with EXTRA flavor for a truly spectacular meal 🍽

Soup of the Day: Mushroom Prime Rib 🍄
Dessert: Chocolate Eclair Torte 🍫

Come on in, we'll save you a seat!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-297-1197
4P-10P

Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs Travis Mantsch Tabitha Sanchez Stevie Gengler Vaquess Miller

11/29/2025

❄Snow Storm of 2025? We’re Still Cooking!

While the flakes are piling up outside, we’ll be braving the blizzard and keeping things warm, cozy, and delicious inside! * We will be keeping watch on the weather & ensuring everyone is safe ☃️*

Join us as we serve up:
🥩 Garlic-Herb Prime Rib – slow-roasted perfection
🍝 Fresh Pasta – handmade and hearty
🥩 Juicy Steaks – grilled just the way you like
🐟 Featured Winter Menu Dish: Stuffed Salmon – rich, savory, and absolutely unforgettable

Bundle up, drive safe, and come enjoy a winter feast worth braving the storm for! ❄️❤️

See you soon!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
262-685-0012

Tour Ozaukee Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs Charlie Berens

11/29/2025

11/27/2025

To allow all of us to spend time with our families, we will be closed today ♥️ Happy Thanksgiving from our family to yours! We will see you tomorrow, Friday 11/28 @ 4P for our delicious Friday Fish Fry, steaks & fresh pasta!

11/25/2025

We're only 2-sleeps away!!

11/23/2025

A gift of $25 feeds 10 puppies.
A gift of $50 vaccinates them.
A gift of any size given during the holiday season is doubled.
We love that math!

Maximize your donation by joining our holiday giving campaign, generously enabled by Russ & Mary Hanson, who will match all donations up to $25,000. Support twice as many WCHS pets, programs and services by visiting wchspets.org/donate

11/21/2025

🥂 Wisconsin Tradition Alert! 🥂

Did you know that the Wednesday before Thanksgiving is Old Fashioned tradition time in Wisconsin? Bars across the state, especially in Milwaukee, would offer $1 Old Fashioneds to welcome hometown crowds and returning college students. It’s the perfect mix of our state’s official cocktail and pre-holiday festivities!

Join us The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg, WI for an old-fashioned tradition! Whether you’re home for the holidays, a local looking to celebrate, or just don’t feel like cooking 🍴

🍝 Homemade All-You-Can-Eat Spaghetti, Meatballs & Garlic Bread
🥃 $1 Rail Old Fashioneds

📍 Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Bring your friends, enjoy great food, and sip a Wisconsin classic!

Dine In Only | While Supplies Last

Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs

At The Old Fashioned, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

11/16/2025

11/05/2025

Join us on Thursdays at The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg for a relaxed evening of good food and great company!

✨ Buy one entrée, get the second entrée $10 off!

Plus, warm up with our scratch-made soups 🍲 Hearty Lasagna Soup and Mushroom Herb Bisque — made fresh & full of flavor.

Come hungry, leave happy. 🍷Dine in only 🍴
📍 3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

At The Old Fashioned, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!