The Old Fashioned Supper Club

The Old Fashioned Supper Club At The Old Fashioned, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

12/12/2025

❄️🥶 It may be freezing outside, but our food is HOT! 🔥
And if that’s not enough, our old fashioneds will warm you up even faster 🥃

Swing on in tonight for:
🐟 Our delicious hand-breaded fish fry (golden fried, baked or blackened)
🥩 Succulent steaks cooked to perfection
🍝 Fresh pasta made with love

Bundle up, head over, and enjoy a truly relaxing evening with us. We’ll keep you warm! ❤️🔥

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Clubs Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens MKEeeeEats Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

I'm not sure about you but I feel like Cabin Fever is starting to set in with all of this snow & the frigid temperatures...
12/06/2025

I'm not sure about you but I feel like Cabin Fever is starting to set in with all of this snow & the frigid temperatures 🥶

We're looking extra forward to our Saturday night prime rib - not only is it encrusted but we're injecting it with EXTRA flavor for a truly spectacular meal 🍽

Soup of the Day: Mushroom Prime Rib 🍄
Dessert: Chocolate Eclair Torte 🍫

Come on in, we'll save you a seat!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-297-1197
4P-10P

Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs Travis Mantsch Tabitha Sanchez Stevie Gengler Vaquess Miller

❄Snow Storm of 2025? We’re Still Cooking! While the flakes are piling up outside, we’ll be braving the blizzard and keep...
11/29/2025

❄Snow Storm of 2025? We’re Still Cooking!

While the flakes are piling up outside, we’ll be braving the blizzard and keeping things warm, cozy, and delicious inside! * We will be keeping watch on the weather & ensuring everyone is safe ☃️*

Join us as we serve up:
🥩 Garlic-Herb Prime Rib – slow-roasted perfection
🍝 Fresh Pasta – handmade and hearty
🥩 Juicy Steaks – grilled just the way you like
🐟 Featured Winter Menu Dish: Stuffed Salmon – rich, savory, and absolutely unforgettable

Bundle up, drive safe, and come enjoy a winter feast worth braving the storm for! ❄️❤️

See you soon!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
262-685-0012

Tour Ozaukee Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs Charlie Berens

11/29/2025
11/27/2025

To allow all of us to spend time with our families, we will be closed today ♥️ Happy Thanksgiving from our family to yours! We will see you tomorrow, Friday 11/28 @ 4P for our delicious Friday Fish Fry, steaks & fresh pasta!

We're only 2-sleeps away!!
11/25/2025

We're only 2-sleeps away!!

11/23/2025

A gift of $25 feeds 10 puppies.
A gift of $50 vaccinates them.
A gift of any size given during the holiday season is doubled.
We love that math!

Maximize your donation by joining our holiday giving campaign, generously enabled by Russ & Mary Hanson, who will match all donations up to $25,000. Support twice as many WCHS pets, programs and services by visiting wchspets.org/donate

11/21/2025

🥂 Wisconsin Tradition Alert! 🥂

Did you know that the Wednesday before Thanksgiving is Old Fashioned tradition time in Wisconsin? Bars across the state, especially in Milwaukee, would offer $1 Old Fashioneds to welcome hometown crowds and returning college students. It’s the perfect mix of our state’s official cocktail and pre-holiday festivities!

Join us The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg, WI for an old-fashioned tradition! Whether you’re home for the holidays, a local looking to celebrate, or just don’t feel like cooking 🍴

🍝 Homemade All-You-Can-Eat Spaghetti, Meatballs & Garlic Bread
🥃 $1 Rail Old Fashioneds

📍 Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Bring your friends, enjoy great food, and sip a Wisconsin classic!

Dine In Only | While Supplies Last

Tour Ozaukee Charlie Berens Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs

At The Old Fashioned, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

11/16/2025
11/05/2025

Join us on Thursdays at The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg for a relaxed evening of good food and great company!

✨ Buy one entrée, get the second entrée $10 off!

Plus, warm up with our scratch-made soups 🍲 Hearty Lasagna Soup and Mushroom Herb Bisque — made fresh & full of flavor.

Come hungry, leave happy. 🍷Dine in only 🍴
📍 3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

At The Old Fashioned, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

Address

3498 Highway 33
Newburg, WI
53060

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 10pm
Thursday 4pm - 10pm
Friday 4pm - 10pm
Saturday 4pm - 10pm

Telephone

+12626850012

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Old Fashioned Supper Club posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share